¥1 million in US stocks bought with the yen cheap in Jun 2007 (¥123) was worth ¥0.65 million unhedged and ¥0.98 million hedged five years later. Bought with the yen at its strongest in Oct 2011 (¥77): ¥2.56 million unhedged, ¥1.89 million hedged. When you bought flipped which was better. Over the full 53 years it was close to even: 10.1% a year unhedged, 9.3% hedged.
What decided it was the yen's level at the start. Starting with the yen cheap, hedging won by 2.3% a year over five years; unhedged won only 32% of the time. Starting with the yen dear, unhedged won by 3.2% a year.
But hedging now costs about 2.7% a year (the short-rate gap). In real Tokyo ETFs since 1 Jul 2020, unhedged returned +305% and hedged +126%: unhedged has won big in recent years.
The biggest past yen surge was 51% in three years (1985→1988). A move from today's ¥157 back to ¥120 would cut foreign assets by 24% in yen.
Starting with a cheap yen, hedging paid off
Currency hedging removes exchange-rate swings in exchange for paying the short-term rate gap. Buying foreign assets with the yen cheap leaves you exposed to a later rebound. The past 50 years show the difference clearly.
US stocks held five years: annual return in yen (average)Every month from March 1973 as a start, held five years (582 cases). Split by the yen's real value when starting (below 98 = cheap, 123+ = dear). It is 62 now.Show the numbers
Unhedged
Hedged
Started with yen cheap
8.2%
10.5%
Middle
9.8%
9.5%
Started with yen dear
12.7%
9.5%
Asset, horizon
Yen at start
Unhedged
Hedged
Difference
Unhedged won
Cases
US stocks・5y
Started with yen cheap
8.2%
10.5%
-2.3%
32%
155
US stocks・5y
Middle
9.8%
9.5%
+0.3%
57%
213
US stocks・5y
Started with yen dear
12.7%
9.5%
+3.2%
76%
214
US stocks・10y
Started with yen cheap
10.0%
11.7%
-1.7%
25%
124
US stocks・10y
Middle
10.1%
10.5%
-0.4%
49%
184
US stocks・10y
Started with yen dear
9.8%
7.7%
+2.2%
79%
214
US 10y bonds・5y
Started with yen cheap
2.3%
4.7%
-2.4%
32%
155
US 10y bonds・5y
Middle
4.1%
4.1%
0.0%
57%
213
US 10y bonds・5y
Started with yen dear
7.6%
4.7%
+2.9%
76%
214
US 10y bonds・10y
Started with yen cheap
4.5%
6.3%
-1.7%
25%
124
US 10y bonds・10y
Middle
4.5%
5.0%
-0.5%
49%
184
US 10y bonds・10y
Started with yen dear
6.1%
4.1%
+2.0%
79%
214
Fifty years of compounding
US stocks: 1 invested, value in yen (dividends reinvested, log scale)1 invested in Mar 1973 is now 173× unhedged and 115× hedged. Hedged is approximated as US returns plus the short-rate gap (actual hedging costs and fees not included). Until around 1980 Japan restricted foreign investment, so hedging was hard in practice.Show the numbers
Date
Unhedged
Hedged
Jan 1974
1×
1×
Jan 1975
1×
1×
Jan 1976
1×
1×
Jan 1977
1×
1×
Jan 1978
1×
1×
Jan 1979
1×
1×
Jan 1980
1×
1×
Jan 1981
1×
2×
Jan 1982
1×
2×
Jan 1983
2×
2×
Jan 1984
2×
2×
Jan 1985
3×
2×
Jan 1986
3×
3×
Jan 1987
3×
4×
Jan 1988
2×
4×
Jan 1989
2×
4×
Jan 1990
3×
5×
Jan 1991
3×
5×
Jan 1992
4×
6×
Jan 1993
4×
7×
Jan 1994
4×
8×
Jan 1995
4×
8×
Jan 1996
5×
11×
Jan 1997
8×
13×
Jan 1998
11×
16×
Jan 1999
12×
20×
Jan 2000
13×
21×
Jan 2001
14×
20×
Jan 2002
13×
16×
Jan 2003
9×
12×
Jan 2004
11×
16×
Jan 2005
11×
17×
Jan 2006
14×
18×
Jan 2007
17×
20×
Jan 2008
15×
18×
Jan 2009
8×
11×
Jan 2010
10×
15×
Jan 2011
11×
18×
Jan 2012
11×
19×
Jan 2013
15×
22×
Jan 2014
21×
27×
Jan 2015
27×
31×
Jan 2016
27×
31×
Jan 2017
32×
37×
Jan 2018
39×
46×
Jan 2019
37×
44×
Jan 2020
45×
52×
Jan 2021
50×
61×
Jan 2022
69×
75×
Jan 2023
72×
67×
Jan 2024
97×
77×
Jan 2025
131×
93×
Jan 2026
153×
105×
Aug 2026
173×
115×
The cost of hedging
Hedging cost guide: US 3-month rate minus Japan overnight rateWhen positive, hedging takes this much off returns each year.Show the numbers
Date
Hedging cost (annual)
Jan 1986
0.0%
Jan 1987
1.1%
Jan 1988
2.1%
Jan 1989
4.2%
Jan 1990
1.1%
Jan 1991
-1.8%
Jan 1992
-1.7%
Jan 1993
-0.9%
Jan 1994
0.7%
Jan 1995
3.5%
Jan 1996
4.5%
Jan 1997
4.5%
Jan 1998
4.6%
Jan 1999
4.1%
Jan 2000
5.3%
Jan 2001
4.9%
Jan 2002
1.6%
Jan 2003
1.2%
Jan 2004
0.9%
Jan 2005
2.3%
Jan 2006
4.2%
Jan 2007
4.7%
Jan 2008
2.2%
Jan 2009
0.0%
Jan 2010
0.0%
Jan 2011
0.1%
Jan 2012
-0.1%
Jan 2013
0.0%
Jan 2014
0.0%
Jan 2015
0.0%
Jan 2016
0.2%
Jan 2017
0.6%
Jan 2018
1.4%
Jan 2019
2.4%
Jan 2020
1.6%
Jan 2021
0.1%
Jan 2022
0.2%
Jan 2023
4.6%
Jan 2024
5.2%
Jan 2025
3.9%
Jan 2026
2.8%
Aug 2026
2.7%
Tokyo S&P 500 ETFs: unhedged (1655) vs hedged (2563), 1 Jul 2020 = 100Adjusted for dividends (Yahoo Finance). The weakening yen from 2021 coincided with rising hedging costs.Show the numbers
Date
Unhedged
Hedged
1 Jul 2020
100
100
6 Aug 2020
105
108
10 Sep 2020
109
110
19 Oct 2020
112
114
24 Nov 2020
114
117
28 Dec 2020
117
121
3 Feb 2021
122
125
11 Mar 2021
130
128
14 Apr 2021
138
135
24 May 2021
138
136
25 Jun 2021
145
140
2 Aug 2021
148
145
6 Sep 2021
152
149
12 Oct 2021
150
143
16 Nov 2021
164
154
21 Dec 2021
161
152
27 Jan 2022
151
141
8 Mar 2022
153
144
12 Apr 2022
176
152
20 May 2022
160
135
23 Jun 2022
163
128
28 Jul 2022
174
137
1 Sep 2022
176
134
7 Oct 2022
174
126
14 Nov 2022
178
134
19 Dec 2022
169
130
25 Jan 2023
168
134
1 Mar 2023
175
133
5 Apr 2023
174
137
12 May 2023
180
137
15 Jun 2023
200
145
20 Jul 2023
206
150
24 Aug 2023
211
147
28 Sep 2023
208
140
2 Nov 2023
208
138
8 Dec 2023
215
148
17 Jan 2024
229
152
21 Feb 2024
244
159
28 Mar 2024
260
167
2 May 2024
258
160
7 Jun 2024
274
170
11 Jul 2024
299
178
16 Aug 2024
272
174
20 Sep 2024
268
178
28 Oct 2024
295
182
2 Dec 2024
299
186
9 Jan 2025
309
182
14 Feb 2025
309
188
24 Mar 2025
283
174
25 Apr 2025
262
168
3 Jun 2025
281
180
7 Jul 2025
301
190
12 Aug 2025
315
194
16 Sep 2025
324
200
22 Oct 2025
341
203
28 Nov 2025
357
205
6 Jan 2026
361
208
10 Feb 2026
361
208
18 Mar 2026
359
202
22 Apr 2026
378
211
1 Jun 2026
406
226
3 Jul 2026
406
222
7 Aug 2026
410
228
11 Sep 2026
394
225
29 Sep 2026
406
226
What a stronger yen takes away
How much foreign assets lose in yen if the dollar falls from today’s level. The second table lists the largest yen surges since 1973, ranked by the three-year fall in USD/JPY (overlapping periods merged).
If USD/JPY goes to
Foreign assets in yen
¥140
-11%
¥130
-17%
¥120
-24%
¥100
-36%
Change from today’s 157.36 (29 Sep 2026), before any move in the assets themselves.
Period
USD/JPY
3-year change
Mar 1985→Mar 1988
258 → 127
-51%
Oct 1975→Oct 1978
302 → 184
-39%
Apr 1992→Apr 1995
134 → 84
-37%
Aug 2008→Aug 2011
109 → 77
-30%
Dec 2005→Dec 2008
118 → 91
-23%
Tools available in Japan
Tool
How currency and rates affect it
Foreign stocks and bonds, unhedged
Gains when the yen weakens and loses when it strengthens. Buying now means buying with the yen at a historically weak level.
Currency-hedged funds and ETFs
Removes most of the currency swing in exchange for paying the short-term rate gap each year (the hedging cost below). Tokyo lists hedged and unhedged versions of the same index (e.g. iShares S&P 500 ETFs 1655 and hedged 2563).
Floating-rate JGBs for individuals (10-year)
The coupon resets every six months (10-year JGB yield × 0.66), so it rises with Japanese rates. It stays in yen, so there is no currency risk.
Yen deposits
No currency risk, but if prices rise faster than the deposit rate, what the money can buy shrinks.
Gold
Gold bought in yen moves with both the dollar gold price and the exchange rate. Its premise is checked on a separate site.